Most detailed review of Mumbai-Goa Vande Bharat Express as a travel option to Goa from Mumbai and from Pune

Hello, avid travelers and dedicated readers! Our journey through the captivating landscapes of India has been rich with experiences, navigating through the bustling local trains, tranquil road trips, and the quick flights that stitch together the far reaches of our nation. Today, we bring you a detailed review of the much-discussed Mumbai-Goa Vande Bharat Express. This review is uniquely designed for our audience in Mumbai and Pune, as the insights and final recommendations differ significantly between travelers from these two cities. We aim to compare this remarkable innovation by Indian Railways with other modes of transportation, while specifically addressing its advantages and drawbacks for those coming from Pune. Read the final, first hand verdict after the review.

1. Effectiveness as an Alternative:

1.1 Flight Comparison:

• Travel Time Differences: One of the most significant advantages of the Vande Bharat Express over flights is the elimination of the need for early airport arrivals, security checks, and the often lengthy boarding processes. While a flight from Mumbai to Goa might take approximately an hour, when you factor in the time to reach the airport, check-in, clear security, and then finally disembark and leave the airport at the destination, the total travel time can easily match or exceed the 7-hour journey of the Vande Bharat Express. For Pune residents, however, the equation also includes the travel time to Panvel Railway Station to catch the Mumbai-Goa Vande Bharat Express.
• Ticket Prices and Baggage: Comparatively, ticket prices for the Vande Bharat Express are quite competitive, especially when you consider the additional costs associated with flights, such as seat selection fees. With flights, the risk of delays and cancellations due to weather or operational issues also looms large, potentially disrupting plans last minute.
• Comfort Levels: The Vande Bharat Express offers a level of comfort akin to what you’d expect in an aircraft, with added benefits such as more legroom, the freedom to move around, and the scenic views of the Western Ghats that no flight can match.

1.2 Road Travel Comparison:

• Time Difference: The road journey from Pune to Goa can be an arduous 10 to 12-hour drive, depending on traffic and weather conditions. This is significantly longer than the train journey, which from Panvel (the nearest boarding point for Pune residents) takes a little over 7 hours to reach Goa.
• Traffic Congestion and Fatigue: Road trips, while offering the flexibility of multiple stops and the enjoyment of scenic beauty, often come with the downside of potential traffic congestion, especially on popular routes like the Mumbai-Pune Expressway. Fatigue for the driver and passengers can also not be ignored, making the train a more comfortable and safer option.
• Comfort and Convenience: The Vande Bharat Express, with its modern amenities, ensures a journey where comfort meets convenience, a stark contrast to the unpredictabilities and discomforts of road travel.

1.3 For Pune Residents:

• Boarding at Panvel Station: For those of you residing in Pune, boarding the Vande Bharat Express from Panvel station is the best option, as that is the nearest railway station enroute. Though the early morning departure time means a very early start from Pune, putting a question mark on whether you should take this option. The travel time from Pune to Panvel can vary, but leaving Pune around 2:00 AM, as we did, factors in ample buffer time for any unforeseen delays on the expressway, which, on our journey, was surprisingly clear. This however, adds an entire night of travel and discomfort to your upcoming journey to Goa.

1.4 Panvel Station Experience:

Upon arrival at Panvel Station in the pre-dawn hours, the first impression was far from welcoming. The station, serving as a crucial junction for many, seemed to have been left in a time warp, reminiscent of the infrastructure from the 1960s. Lighting was minimal, creating a less than secure atmosphere, and the lack of clear signages made navigation a challenge, especially for first-time visitors.

The platforms were littered, indicating a need for better maintenance and cleanliness. The waiting rooms were overcrowded, with many people appearing to use them more as a temporary shelter than a transit point. The washrooms, too, were in a deplorable state, making it a no-go zone for us.

Concerns and Improvements Needed:

• Upgrade Required: The station desperately needs a comprehensive upgrade to match the modernity of the trains it serves, particularly the Vande Bharat Express.
• Cleanliness and Security: Improved lighting, clear signage, and enhanced security measures would make early morning or late night travel much safer and more convenient.
• Facilities: Better maintenance of washrooms and waiting areas is crucial to provide a comfortable waiting experience for passengers.

2. Boarding Experience:

The boarding experience was a mix of chaos and relief. The announcement of the platform number for the Vande Bharat Express was made merely 15 minutes before its arrival, sending passengers, including us, into a frenzy to reach the correct platform in time. The station’s layout and the late announcement did little to ease the stress of boarding, especially for those of us burdened with luggage.

However, once on the correct platform, the process was swift, thanks in part to the train’s punctual arrival. The staff at Panvel, though overwhelmed by the rush, managed to maintain a semblance of order and were helpful in guiding passengers to their respective coaches.

2.1 Train Interiors Review:

The interior of the Vande Bharat Express was a stark contrast to the station it departed from. The coaches boasted a clean, modern design with a comfortable seating arrangement. We were in the Executive Chair Car, which promised more space and the luxury of 360-degree rotating seats, although we faced a hiccup with the seat rotation due to the reclined seats ahead of us.

Facilities:

• Seating Comfort: The legroom in the Executive Chair Car was exceptional, allowing passengers to stretch out comfortably.
• Cleanliness: The coaches were well-maintained, reflecting a high standard of cleanliness.
• Luggage Racks and Charging Points: Despite the absence of designated heavy luggage storage, the overhead racks were spacious enough for large suitcases. Each seat came equipped with a USB charging port and a standard 3-pin socket, catering to all our power needs.
• Toilets: The toilets were reminiscent of those in modern airliners, featuring vacuum commodes and clean, well-stocked amenities.

Unique Features:

• The panoramic windows offered breathtaking views of the landscape, enhanced by the smooth retractable blinds that allowed control over the amount of natural light entering the coach.

2.2 Services:

Food and Beverage: The quality and variety of food served on board were commendable. The breakfast was particularly impressive, with options catering to both vegetarian and non-vegetarian preferences. The meal was well-presented, and the serving staff, though needing a bit more polish in their skills, were polite and eager to assist.

Onboard Entertainment: One of the highlights was the onboard infotainment system, which could be accessed via passengers’ phones. This system provided real-time train information, along with a selection of shows, songs, and movies, making the journey more enjoyable.

Wi-Fi Connectivity and Housekeeping: While Wi-Fi connectivity was not mentioned, the cleanliness maintained throughout the journey spoke volumes of the efficient housekeeping services onboard.

Overall, the services provided on the Vande Bharat Express significantly enhanced the travel experience, making the journey from Panvel to Goa not just comfortable but also enjoyable.

3. Ticket Prices:

The Vande Bharat Express offers ticket prices that are competitively positioned between the cost of flights and road travel for the Mumbai to Goa route. For the Chair Car, the ticket is priced at ₹1850, and for the Executive Chair Car, it costs ₹3360. When compared to flights, which can vary greatly in price based on timing and booking window but often include additional costs for baggage, the train offers a solid middle ground. Road travel costs, meanwhile, would depend on the vehicle’s fuel efficiency, toll fees, and other incidental expenses, potentially making the train a more economical option for solo travelers or small groups.

Value Proposition: Based on the experience, the value proposition of the Vande Bharat Express is high. The comfort, convenience, and array of services offered onboard justify the ticket price, especially when considering the added benefits of scenic views and spacious seating, which are not available in flights or personal vehicles.

4. Journey Comfort and Travel Time:

4.1. Journey Comfort:

The Vande Bharat Express excels in providing comfort. The air-conditioning was effective and adjustable, ensuring a pleasant environment irrespective of the outside weather. Noise levels within the coach were minimal, thanks to the train’s excellent soundproofing, allowing for easy conversation and relaxation. Legroom, especially in the Executive Chair Car, was ample, enabling passengers to stretch out comfortably.

The route offered stunning scenic views, particularly as the train navigated through the Western Ghats, providing passengers with a visual treat that is simply unavailable on flights and difficult to enjoy on road trips due to the focus required in driving.

4.2 Travel Time

The actual travel time from Panvel to Madgaon was slightly over 7 hours, closely matching the advertised schedule. The journey was remarkably smooth, with the train maintaining a consistent speed throughout. There were no noticeable delays, and the overall comfort level made the time pass quickly.

4.3 Boarding and Deboarding Experiences:

Disembarking at Madgaon station was less than ideal. The train was stationed at an outer platform, lacking a proper platform, which necessitated navigating a makeshift, unstable ramp. This aspect of the journey was a stark contrast to the onboard experience and could pose difficulties for those with heavy luggage or mobility issues.

5. Things to Improve:

• Platform Information: Providing earlier and clearer information about the train’s platform would significantly reduce boarding stress.
• Deboarding Facilities: Improving the deboarding process at stations like Madgaon, with better platform alignment and accessibility, is crucial.
• Luggage Storage: Incorporating designated spaces for heavy luggage near the coach entrances could enhance convenience.

Positive Points:

The most impressive aspects of the journey were the high level of comfort, the efficient service, and the overall value. Unique features like the onboard infotainment system, panoramic windows, and the clean, modern toilets stood out, making the Vande Bharat Express a memorable way to travel.

ALSO READ | Vande Bharat Sleeper Train: Innovative features that will outshine Rajdhani in styling, comfort, and safety

6. Final Verdict:

For travelers from Mumbai and Pune to Goa, the Vande Bharat Express is a commendable option, balancing speed, comfort, and convenience at a reasonable cost. It is particularly recommended for those seeking a relaxed journey with the added benefit of scenic beauty along the way.

Pros:

• Competitive ticket pricing
• High comfort levels with ample legroom and effective air-conditioning
• Convenient travel times matching advertised schedules
• Scenic route offering beautiful landscapes

Cons:

• Early morning travel from Pune to Panvel may be inconvenient for some
• Boarding process can be stressful due to late platform announcements and the dilapidated condition of Panvel Railway Station, serving as a crucial transit point for travelers coming from Pune to catch the train.
• Deboarding at Madgaon needs improvement for better accessibility

For Mumbai residents, the option is highly recommended. However, for those living in Pune, it is not advisable due to the following reasons:

• Extended Travel Time and Costs: For Pune residents, reaching Panvel entails an additional travel time of nearly 5 hours, accompanied by increased travel expenses.
• Poor Conditions at Panvel Station: The Panvel Railway Station is noted for its unwelcoming conditions, detracting from the overall travel experience.
• Brief Train Stopovers at Panvel: The train’s halt time at Panvel Station is too brief, making it challenging for passengers to board comfortably.
• Inconvenient Departure Times: Travelers from Pune must start their journey at odd hours to arrive in Panvel by early morning, in time to catch the train.

For bookings and more information, travelers are advised to visit the official Indian Railways website or use the IRCTC mobile app, ensuring secure and direct access to ticket reservations and train details.

Conclusion – Mumbai-Goa Vande Bharat Express

The Mumbai-Goa Vande Bharat Express represents a significant leap forward in the realm of Indian rail travel, merging speed, luxury, and efficiency in a package that appeals to a wide range of travelers. This comprehensive review sought to explore every facet of the journey, from the convenience of boarding for Pune residents to the unparalleled comfort and amenities offered onboard, comparing it against the traditional travel options of flights and road journeys.

Our journey aboard the Mumbai-Goa Vande Bharat Express was more than just a travel experience; it was a glimpse into the future of rail travel in India, where convenience does not come at the expense of comfort or the joy of the journey itself. Despite the early morning challenges faced by Pune residents in reaching Panvel station, the train’s modern amenities, prompt service, and the scenic beauty it traverses make it a superior choice for travel to Goa.

There are areas where improvements can be made, particularly in the boarding and deboarding processes, and in enhancing passenger information systems. Addressing these concerns will undoubtedly elevate the experience to new heights, making it seamless from start to finish.

In conclusion, for those debating between the various modes of travel from Mumbai and Pune to Goa, the Mumbai-Goa Vande Bharat Express offers an enticing blend of speed, comfort, and panoramic beauty, making it a standout choice. It caters not only to the needs of the modern traveler but does so with an eye towards the evolving expectations for rail travel. Whether you’re traveling for leisure, business, or the sheer joy of discovery, the Mumbai-Goa Vande Bharat Express invites you to embark on a journey that promises to be as delightful as the destination itself.